The key aspect of any industrial kiln is that it creates an immensely hot space within the rotating drum. However, how the inner chamber becomes hot can differ between kilns. There are two primary types of firing methods: direct-fired and indirect-fired. These have substantially different outcomes, and it’s important to match the firing method to the process you’re attempting to implement.
These are the major differences between direct- and indirect-fired industrial kilns.
I. Direct-Fired
In a direct-fired industrial kiln, the heat source is directly within the kiln itself. This means the kiln must be lined with strong refractory bricks, or a similar inner surface, to trap the heat and reflect it inwards.
Direct-fired kilns are used when maximum heat is called for, such as pyroprocessing. They are useful for destroying organic matter to reclaim inorganic components, such as separating metals during material recycling.
However, in many cases, the materials being fired inside a kiln should not come directly into contact with the heat source. In that case, an indirect-fired kiln should be used.
II. Indirect-Fired
With an indirect-fired kiln, the heat source is located outside the kiln, typically either gas flames or electric burners. The heat is transferred through the skin of the kiln to heat up the interior. As such, indirect-fired kilns typically have much thinner inner linings, so that it’s easy for heat to transfer through.
These are most typically used when the materials inside cannot withstand direct contact with the heat source.
However, indirect-fired kilns have other advantages as well. For example, it is much easier to maintain and shape heat throughout the full length of the kiln when the heat source is located outside. The heat source can be more easily controlled, allowing for highly precise shaping of the heat envelope.
Along the same lines, this higher degree of control also makes it simpler to maintain specific atmospheres within the kiln.
Also, indirect-fired kilns tend to release less gas from within the kiln. This, in turn, means that there’s less need for treatment, redirecting, or otherwise dealing with these hot gasses. In some cases, this can lead to more-efficient heating with less energy waste.
Material Contact
Direct-fired kilns expose materials directly to flames and combustion gases, making them suitable for processes that can tolerate this exposure. The immediate contact with heat facilitates rapid heating of materials. In contrast, indirect-fired kilns heat materials through the kiln’s shell, without direct exposure to flames, protecting sensitive materials from combustion gases.
Heat Transfer Mechanisms
The heat in direct-fired kilns is transferred to the material via convection and radiation, leading to quick temperature changes. Indirect-fired kilns use conduction, as the heat from an external source is gradually transferred through the kiln’s shell, allowing for a more even and controlled process.
Temperature Control
Direct-fired kilns can quickly reach high temperatures but may fluctuate, requiring vigilant control. Indirect-fired kilns offer more precise and steady temperature control, beneficial for processes needing consistent heat application.
Contamination Risks for Direct-Fire Kilns
There’s a higher contamination risk with direct-fired kilns as materials are in contact with combustion gases. Indirect-fired kilns minimize this risk by isolating the material from gases, crucial for producing pure materials.
Choosing Direct-Fired vs. Indirect-Fired Industrial Kilns for Different Applications
The choice between direct and indirect-fired kilns depends on process requirements. Direct-fired kilns are chosen for their efficiency in processes where material contact with gases is permissible. Indirect-fired kilns are preferred for contaminant-free processing and when precise temperature control is needed.
Industrial Rotary Kiln Services & Solutions
Kiln Technology Company Company Company has decades of experience working with rotary kilns of all types. Whether you need a new kiln, maintenance, parts, or even decommissioning, we can make it happen! Click here for a free estimate on your job and get professional rotary kiln services.